Justice Mukherjee commission that went to Russia has returned without finding anything. Some people had suggested that after faking a plane crash in Taiwan, Subhash Bose had reached Russia and the Commission had gone there to find the truth about it. Some of the leads were fake and some were just accounts published in books of which the Commission requested an English Translation.
The truth, according to some is in the KGB archives. So Justice Mukherjee called up KGB and asked if they had any documents about Bose and they said no. So he just walked away.
Authorities of the Central Archive of the KGB, Central State Archive of Russian Federation Defence, Russian State Library, State Archive of Russian Federation, Russian State Military Archive and the Russian State Historical Archives for the Far East have informed the Commission that they had no documents relevant to its terms of enquiry, Mukherjee said.[Mukherjee Commission returns sans Netaji documents]
If Justice Mukherjee had watched even a single James Bond movie he would have known that this is not the way to get information out from such places. I am not suggesting that the Honorable Justice drown a Martini, shaken, but not stirred and crash into the archives in a Tank, but instead rely on some investigative reporters who know to get information out. Even if someone asked for chai-paani money for providing the information, the Justice will have to send a written note to the Ministry of Home Affairs, who will forward the note to a financial desk, who will then forward it to the senior most officer who is on a five year vacation. Well, you get the picture. A Govt. appointed commission operating in an honest straightforward way will only be able to collect limited information.
So far from all the information available, it seems like Subhash Bose was not in Russia and that story too was planted like the plane crash.
Previous Links: Subhash Bose: The Investigations – II, Subhash Bose: The investigations, How did Subhash Bose die?
7 thoughts on “Subhash Bose: Was not in Russia”
Sorry. This is very very off topic. But check this out. Mallu Rap!!
The commission wasnt allowed to check the KGB and FSB documents. Britain has stated clearly that they would declassify materials on Bose only after 2021. Some key individuals like A Kolesnikov were declared ‘not traceable’ by the RUS govt. The commission tried its best, but the result was always on the cards especially when the PMO was reluctant to contact its Russian counterpart prior to the commission’s visit.
Cofounder – Mission Netaji
The “Previous Links” do not work.
Just change the .html extension to .php in the URL and you should get it. I need to fix those.
Who killed Netaji?
Congress killed Netaji files. Why Nehru betrayed Netaji. Gold-Diamond loaded Trunks took Air journey. Where was wealth of Azad Hind Bank? What said JanmBhoomi editor? What said Nehru to UK PM?
Who were involved in the conspiracy to murder Subhash Chandra Bose, Dr. Shyama Prasad Mukerjee and Lal Bahadur Shstri? It is not possible to find out answers of all these in this limited worded article.
Researcher Professor Purabi Roy and her fellows, who have estimated the worth of INA funds and who are prominent deponent before the Mukherjee commission, have some light to throw on the issue. But Report of Mukherjee commission is totally rejected by Congress led Govt. without giving any reason. Congress ally CPM also suspects congress move and wants the discussion in the parliament on the Report.
Threatening to Researchers
Did Netaji really die in the 1945 plane crash? Incredibly hard facts have now emerged from Moscow vaults. Netaji was in fact very much alive till at least 1946 one full year after his supposed “death”. Russian archives had yielded two precious documents. The first concerned a discussion that Joseph Stalin had with his defense minister Voroschilov and foreign affairs minister Molotov in 1946. The second was a report filed by a Soviet field agent stationed in India, also in 1946.
One more British archive document also states that the entire theory of the plane crash, in Taihuku (Japan), was pre-planned and contrived. In fact as late as December 20, 1945, a Japanese newspaper even reported that Bose was on his way to the Soviet Union and passed through Tokyo.
Find the killer of Netaji
British Prime Minister Clements Attlee decided Let him remain where he (Subhash C. Bose) is now. This decision was taken in October 1945. It clearly indicates that he was alive even in Oct 1945.
Netaji was reported to be alive even after 1945 by the British intelligence from Teheran and Kabul quoting the Russian embassy officials. This was even stated in the Shah Nawaz commission report (File No. 10/ Mis/ INA-pp 38, 39).
In 1946, Gallacher, a British communist party worker publicly criticised the then Irish President D Valera for welcoming Netaji in Doublin! D Valera didnt deny this. He visited India after 1946 and even commented publicly I expected to meet Bose here!
The British intelligence has reported that Nehru knew where Netaji was. Nehru took the Foreign Affairs portfolio himself and appointed none other than Vijayalekshmi Pandit as the ambassador to Russia!
After her term was over, Dr S.Radhakrishnan became the representative to Russia. Dr Saroj Das of Calcutta University told his friend Dr R.C.Muzumdar that Radhakrishnan had told him that Netaji was in Russia.
Former Indian ambassador Dr Satyanarayana Sinha once met Goga, the son of Abani Mukherjee, a revolutionist in the Russian communist party; who told him that his father and Netaji were prisoners in adjacent cells in Siberia. He also told Sinha that Netaji had assumed the name Khilsai Malang there.
The most shocking of all information it contained was that Netaji had posted a letter from Russia to Nehru, telling that he wished to come back and he also asked Nehru to make amendments for his come back!
You may confirm this from the parliamentary records from 3rd August 1977; and the files published by the British government.
As reported in every newspaper at that time, daughter of Stalin Swetlana said in Delhi that Netaji was in Siberias yarkutaskjail. She also gave barrack No. also.
Speaking to the Hindu, Prof. Guha lent evidence to the view that Subhash Chandra Bose died in a Soviet Prison. He noted that Joseph Stalin was crueler than Adolf Hitler.
A Soviet agent named V G Sayadyants who was based in Mumbai reported home that “Bose is the only hope for Soviet Russia,”
The new findings are based on declassified documents in the Russian military archives in Paddolsk, and from the British archives. They were discovered by three researchers-Purabi Ray, Hari Vasudevan and Shobanlal Dutta Gupta-working on the history of communist movement in India. The plot has thickened even deeper with the admission by these researchers that they have been receiving threatening calls from unidentified persons asking them to suspend all further inquiries and end the government-funded research. Fear for security led the work on the project to be stopped shortly, around the middle of 2000. For Details: http://www.swordoftruth.com/swordoftruth/archives/byauthor/shamolimitra/tmbnd.html
Why Mukherjee Commission Report rejected?
Congress does not want the nation to know Jawaharlal Nehru’s actions and role in betraying Netaji. The previous two Commissions: Shah Nawaz Committee and the Khosla Commission were appointed by the Congress government. For bringing truth BJP let NDA Govt. appointed Mukherjee Commission.
I saw Netaji alive after his alleged plane crash is disclosed by Capt Abbas Ali, an old INA freedom fighter.
It was unbelievable that Netaji died in an air crash said by Suresh Chandra Bose elder brother of Subhash C.Bose. He deposing before the Khosla Commission charged Mr Shah Nawaz Khan with “playing Netaji false”
Deposing before the Khosla Commission, Dr Satyanarayan Sinha said Colonel Habibur Rehman had confessed to him at Patna in 1946 that he had had told a lie when he said that Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose died in a plane crash in Taipeh on August 18, 1945
Killing of Netaji files by Congress Governments
Most of the secret files about Netaji, that were maintained by Pandit Nehru himself as “P.M.’s special” files, one of which included all communications connected with INA Defense Committee, were reported by the Indira Gandhi Government as “either missing or destroyed”. It will not be easy to presume that Netaji’s communication to Nehru and a copy of Nehru’s letter to Attlee have also been destroyed. These files were dealt with by the personal secretary of Pt Nehru – Mohmd Yunus.
Nehru’s shocking role in betraying Netaji
Shyamlal jain, the confidential steno of the INA Defense Committee, in the course of his deposition, made a shocking revelation about Nehru’s attitude toward Netaji,Later Nehru asked me to type a letter on his letterhead. Mr.Nehru addressed that letter to Mr.Clamment Attlee the then PM of Britain, in which Mr.Attlee was informed about the contents of that hand written note regarding Mr.Subhash entry into Russian territory.
“I solemnly affirm and state on oath that thereafter Shri Jawaharlal Nehru gave me four papers from his writing pad to make four copies of a letter, which he would dictate to me on typewriter, which I also complied. The contents of the letter, as far as I could remember, were as follows
Dear Mr. Attlee:
I understand from a reliable source that Subhas Chandra Bose, your war criminal, has been allowed to enter Russian territory by Stalin. This is a clear treachery and betrayal of faith by the Russians. As Russia has been an ally of the British-Americans, it should not have been done. Please take note of it and do what you consider proper and fit.
Two important website:
Witness says Japanese killed Netaji (October 21, 1970)
in any murder case , the lier is to be suspected. Japan has spread the false story of taihoku ai crash. so japan is to be suspected. Netaji’s close associate Mr Deb Nath Dass, deposing before the Khosla commission said that “in 1954 he came to the conclusion that if Netaji had died it was not in the same plane and that the Japanese had played some foul game with them” .
Japan killed netaji .
Japan and British were allies in the first world war. so their spies were secretly connectd. after the second world war, the japanese spies restored their links with british and arranged netaji’s murder with a purpose to cunduct appeasment of british and purchasae security for their royal family. as a result , japa got many favor from british anf jap royal family was never not punished for war-crime.